What: American Fight Promotions 101
When: Saturday, February 22, 2025
Where: Columbus Athenaeum in Columbus, Ohio
Odds Courtesy of BetMGM. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), Call 1-800-GAMBLER (US), Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY), Call 1-800-327-5050 (MA).
Bantamweight Bout (135 lbs): Josh Smith (12-10) vs. Mo Miller (8-4)
Mo Miller -220
Josh Smith +190
The main event of AFP 101 sees Mo Miller fight Josh Smith at bantamweight.
Miller is 32 and represents Xtreme Couture in Las Vegas but hails from Ohio. Miller was a standout Division II collegiate wrestler and became a top MMA prospect after tallying a 6-0 record in the amateur ranks. Miller turned pro in 2019 and won his first five fights, including a win on Dana White's Contender Series, but was not awarded a UFC contract. Since then, Miller has gone 2-4 and is looking to rebuild his confidence and return to the UFC level. His wrestling is excellent, as is his ground and pound, but poor submission defense has cost him in his recent fights.
Smith is 36 and fights out of the American Top Team in Coconut Creek, Florida. Smith has been a pro since 2014 and he has fought all over North America, including racking up experience against former or current UFC fighters like Chad Anheliger, Jay Perrin, Charalampos Grigoriou, Justin Scoggins, and Da'Mon Blackshear. He is a reasonably well-rounded fighter who has seen the majority of his fights end inside the distance. However, he has struggled to remain consistent in the last few years and was knocked out in 25 seconds in his last outing.
Even though Miller has struggled lately, I still think he is the better fighter and should be able to control this fight with his wrestling. I am going with Miller at -220 to win, over 1.5 rounds, and leaning toward Miller winning by knockout via ground and pound.
Pick: Mo Miller -220, By KO/TKO -120
Flyweight Bout (125 lbs): Kendale Young (2-3) vs. Asher Frederick (4-1)
Asher Frederick -550
Kendale Young +450
We have Kendale Young taking on Asher Frederick in co-main event flyweight action.
Young is 32 and fights out of Reaction MMA in Nicholasville, Kentucky. A long-time veteran of the Kentucky regional MMA scene, Young went 3-1 in the amateur ranks before going pro in 2014. He then won his first pro fight by knockout but suffered two straight losses, followed by six years off. Since returning to the cage, Young is 1-1. All of his fights have ended by stoppage. From what I have seen, he is a fast starter but tends to tire as the fights go into the later rounds.
Frederick is 25 and trains locally at Ronin Training Center in Columbus, Ohio, but also spends time at Xtreme Couture in Las Vegas. Frederick had a terrific 7-2 amateur MMA run before he went pro in 2023, and since then, he has won four of his five fights. Frederick has solid striking skills and has shown he has the cardio to go the distance.
I see Young starting strong but fatiguing as this fight goes on, and then Frederick will pour it on and get the finish. Go with Frederick at -550, but find some value at over 1.5 rounds at +130.
Pick: Asher Frederick -550, Over 1.5 Rounds +130
Middleweight Bout (185 lbs): David Richardson (1-4) vs. Dom Johns (1-3)
Dom Johns -140
David Richardson +120
Middleweights David Richardson and Dom Johns collide on this card.
Richardson is 33 and fights out of Champion's MMA in Millersburg, Ohio. A pro since 2023, Richardson won his pro debut but has since lost four straight fights, including two losses by knockout. Before going pro, Richardson had a 5-4 mark in the amateur ranks. One thing to like about Richardson is the activity, as he fought twice last year, but the results just haven't been there for him.
Johns is 28 and trains at Ohio's Coshocton Boxing Club. Johns had a long amateur MMA career, going 7-7, and he turned pro in 2024, losing his first three fights by stoppage before bouncing back with a nice knockout win in his last fight. It was certainly good to see Johns get back into the win column, but it's also hard to ignore all those stoppage losses before it.
It's tough to call here, as both men have been very inconsistent at the pro ranks. However, since Johns has some momentum coming into this fight, I'll take Johns at -140 to win. I also like the under 1.5 at -250 here as I see someone getting finished in this fight, likely in round one.
Pick: Dom Johns -140, Under 1.5 Rounds -250
Lightweight Bout (155 lbs): Darrin Gibbs (4-13) vs. TJ Rigel (4-2)
TJ Rigel -1200
Darrin Gibbs +800
Lightweight action sees Darren Gibbs battle TJ Rigel.
Gibbs is 40 and fights out of Allegiance Gym in Sterling Heights, Michigan. After a 7-4 amateur run, Gibbs went pro in 2016 and has mostly struggled in the professional ranks, losing most of his fights. It is worth noting that after opening his pro career 1-9, he has gone 3-4 since then, so there has been some progress, but he still has a losing record. His ground game is his best attribute, as he holds several submission wins, but he has been knocked out too many times.
Rigel is 34 and fights out of Immortal MMA in Lewis Center, Ohio. He had a tidy 6-1 run in the amateur ranks and then turned pro in 2016, winning his first three pro matches before dropping two in a row and then getting back into the win column in his last fight. He is known for his wrestling, and the majority of his fights have gone the distance. It is worth noting that Rigel returned to the cage last November after taking a three-year hiatus and picked up a win.
I'm going with Rigel, who is significantly younger and should hold the wrestling advantage. Take Rigel at -1200, and I am leaning over 1.5 at +130 as I see a decision.
Pick: TJ Rigel -1200, Over 1.5 +130
Flyweight Bout (125 lbs): Alex Poinar (4-3, 1 NC) vs. Nigel Crosswell (1-3)
Alex Poinar -160
Nigel Crosswell +140
At flyweight, Alex Poinar fights Nigel Crosswell.
Poinar is 32 and fights out Xtreme Couture in Las Vegas. After going 6-1 as an amateur, Poinar went pro in 2017 and quickly won his first two pro bouts. He then lost three in a row to lose momentum, but he is unbeaten over his last three bouts. Poinar is a well-rounded fighter and trains at a good gym, but his lack of durability has hurt him so far.
Crosswell is 25 and he trains at Crosswell MMA in Hamilton, Ontario. Following a 5-9 run in the amateur ranks, Crosswell went pro in 2019 and lost his first three fights, including two by stoppage, before scoring a knockout win in his last fight. It was nice to see Crosswell win his last fight, but it was nearly two years ago, and it's hard to know where he's now.
This is a tricky fight to predict, given both men have struggled so far at the pro level. Still, I'd lean toward Poinar, who has more experience and trains at a better camp. Take Poinar to win as a -160 favorite and go with under 1.5 rounds at -175 as a finish seems likely here either way.
Pick: Alex Poinar -160, Under 1.5 Rounds -175




