What: AFP 5
When: Saturday, February 21, 2026
Where: Cherry Valley Hotel in Newark, Ohio
Odds Courtesy of BetMGM. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (US), Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY), 1-800-327-5050 (MA), 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), 1-800-981-0023 (PR), Contact ConnexOntario at 1-866-531-2600 (ON).
Bantamweight Bout (135 lbs): Robert Presley (3-1) vs. Alex Poinar (5-3)
Robert Presley -275
Alex Poinar +225
In the main event of AFP 5, Robert Presley fights Alex Polinar at bantamweight.
Presley is 29 and trains at VO2 Fitness in Newark, Ohio, the same town as the event. Presley went pro in 2021 and has fought four times since, losing his debut before picking up three straight wins, including a knockout at AFP 103 last summer. In addition to his pro MMA experience, Presley has numerous professional boxing matches, giving him a ton of combat sports experience.
Also originally from Ohio, 33-year-old Poinar now trains out of Xtreme Couture in Las Vegas. A pro since 2019, Poinar has gone undefeated over his last four fights, including a submission win at AFP 101 last February. Despite his recent success, it's hard not to forget that Poinar once lost three straight fights by knockout. Going up against someone with Presley's striking acumen could certainly pose a problem.
You have to credit Poinar for his recent hot streak, but Presley is the more experienced fighter with legitimate KO power. Take Presley to win by knockout.
**Pick: Robert Presley by KO/TKO -150 **
Middleweight Bout (185 lbs): Myles Robinson (4-2) vs. David Richardson (3-5)
Myles Robinson -350
David Richardson +300
In this co-main event bout, Ohio's Robinson takes on Kentucky's Richardson at middleweight.
Robinson is 31 and fights out of Immortal Martial Arts Center in Lewis Center, Ohio. A pro since 2021, Robinson won his first four fights by knockout before losing his last two by stoppage. Now, he steps back into the cage on a 15-month layoff. That said, he is a powerful fighter with plenty of knockout power in his fists.
34-year-old Richardson turned pro in 2023, but has struggled with consistency, and has been unable to string together two wins in a row. That said, he did win his last fight this past November, and he previously won under the AFP banner, scoring a submission at AFP 101 last February.
Both men have finishing ability, so I expect an exciting fight for as long as it lasts. Although he has lost his last two bouts, I still have to go with Robinson to win by stoppage.
Pick: Myles Robinson by KO/TKO -200
Light Heavyweight Bout (205 lbs): Jon Cunningham (2-1) vs. Chaz Blevins (0-0)
Jon Cunningham +400
Chaz Blevins -500
Light heavyweights meet when John Cunningham takes on Chaz Blevins.
Cunningham is 30 and trains at Strong Style Fight Team in Independence, Ohio. He turned pro in 2021 and won his debut by knockout. Cunningham then signed with PFL and was knocked out in his lone appearance in that promotion, but bounced back with a knockout in his last fight. Now, he steps back into the cage after a layoff of more than two years.
Blevins is 24 and fights out of Hybrid Martial Arts in Lexington, Kentucky. This fight marks Blevins' pro debut after a successful amateur MMA career, where he went 6-0 with all victories coming by stoppage. He also has amateur boxing experience. Overall, Blevins is a promising prospect poised to make a significant impact here at AFP.
While Cunningham can win by knockout, I have to go with Blevins to have a successful pro debut here, and likely by knockout. I'll play it safe here and take under 1.5 rounds for my best value bet.
Pick: Under 1.5 Rounds -300
Bantamweight Bout (135 lbs): Alex Gordy (1-1) vs. Zach Westlund (1-0)
Alex Gordy +600
Zach Westlund -800
Bantamweights kick off the pro portion of the card when Alex Gordy takes on Zach Westlund.
Gordy is 27 and trains at Bad Apple MMA in Columbus, Georgia. He was a top prospect as an amateur, going 6-0 before turning pro. Since then, Gordy has gone 1-1, with both of his pro fights ending inside the distance, although it's been over a year since his last fight.
Westlund is 26 and fights out of Queen City Grappling Club in Middletown, Ohio. He made his pro debut last year and won by decision. That came after a successful amateur MMA career, during which he lost his first fight but then won four straight before turning pro.
The odds seem high here, but at the same time, I have to take Westund, who seems like the prospect with more potential. Take Westlund to win, but for a best bet, I'll go under 2.5 rounds, as you are getting plus money in a fight where a finish is possible.
Pick: Under 2.5 Rounds +125




