What: Cage Titans 71
When: Saturday, May 24, 2025
Where: Plymouth Memorial Hall in Plymouth, Massachusetts
Odds Courtesy of BetMGM. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-327-5050 (MA), 1-800-GAMBLER (U.S.).
CT Bantamweight Title Bout (135 lbs): Andrew Valdina (6-0) vs. Joe Penafiel (11-6)
Andrew Valdina -400
Joe Penafiel +275
The main event of Cage Titans 71 is a CT bantamweight title bout between champion Joe Penafiel and challenger Andrew Valdina.
Penafiel is 38 and fights out of Fusion X-Cel Performance in Ocoee, Florida. A pro since 2018, Penafiel has fought all over the U.S. against high-level competition, including fights against several UFC fighters such as Austin Bashi, Vince Morales, and Da'Mon Blackshear. He is very tough, experienced, and has a career record of 5-0 at Plymouth Memorial Hall, where he returns after over two years away to defend his bantamweight championship.
Valdina is 28 and trains at the New England Cartel in Haverhill, Massachusetts. He went pro in 2022 and has won all six fights so far, including five wins by stoppage. Valdina is dangerous everywhere, including solid striking and an excellent ground game. He is one of the best fighters in CT right now and someone the UFC matchmakers could be interested in.
While Penafiel is the defending champion and highly experienced, I like Valdina to win this fight. He's far younger, he's in phenomenal shape, and he has that undefeated mindset. Take Valdina to win, and I see this one going the distance.
Pick: Andrew Valdina -400, By Decision Prop +250
Vacant CT Women's Strawweight Title Bout (115 lbs): Hilarie Rose (9-7) vs. Ariana Melendez (5-1)
Ariana Melendez -600
Hilarie Rose +360
The co-main event of Cage Titans 71 is a women's strawweight title bout between Hilarie Rose and Ariana Melendez.
Rose is 32 and reps USMMA in Bellingham, Massachusetts. A pro since 2018, Rose has fought all over the country, including a tough defeat against Cheyanne Vlismas on Dana White's Contender Series in 2020. She has been inconsistent during her MMA career, but to give Rose a lot of credit, she has looked phenomenal lately with three straight wins with Cage Titans. However, Rose has been submitted three times, which could be a big issue against Melendez.
Melendez is 29 and fights out of Fusion X-Cel Performance in Ocoee, Florida, the same gym as Joe Penafiel. She went pro in 2021 and started her career in Invicta FC, where she lost to current UFC standout Fatime Kline in her second pro bout. She then fought for Cage Titans in 2022, winning her lone bout with the promotion, before fighting in Florida for her last three bouts. She is a solid prospect with good grappling skills and the ability to go the distance. Melendez is someone who could be on the UFC's radar soon.
I have to give Rose credit because she has recently turned her career around. That said, Melendez should have a significant advantage on the ground, and I like her to win this fight. Take Melendez to win with an early submission. If she is successful here and wins the belt, I expect the UFC to be very interested in Melendez.
Pick: Ariana Melendez -600, Under 1.5 Rounds -150
Welterweight Bout (170 lbs): Zack Davis (9-6) vs. Jack Congdon (6-1)
Jack Congdon -1600
Zack Davis +700
In welterweight action, we have Zach Davis against Jack Congdon.
Davis is 36 and trains at Sabens MMA in Carbondale, Illinois. He has been a pro fighter for seven years and the majority of his bouts have ended inside the distance. Davis has shown knockout power throughout his career but also weakness in his ground game, as he has been submitted three times.
Congdon is 27 and fights out of Lakeville MMA in Lakeville, Massachusetts. A pro since 2022, all seven of his fights have taken place in Cage Titans, and he has won six of seven bouts, with all of his wins coming by first-round stoppage. Since suffering his lone career defeat last May, Congdon has won two straight fights to regain his confidence and get scouts interested in him again.
Davis is a solid veteran who has fought a higher level of competition than Congdon, but his age, mixed with his weakness on the ground, makes me like this matchup for his opponent. Go with Congdon to pick up a first-round submission victory.
Pick: Jack Congdon -1600, Under 1.5 Rounds -300
Catchweight Bout (140 lbs): Nick Eldridge (3-0) vs. Phil LoCigno (3-0)
Nick Eldridge -220
Phil LoCigno +165
At a catchweight of 140 lbs, Nick Eldridge squares off against Phil LoCigno.
Eldridge is 30 and trains at Nostos MMA in Somersworth, New Hampshire. Following a successful amateur MMA career, Eldridge turned pro this year and has already tallied a perfect 3-0 record with three finishes. He looks like the real deal and could be a force to be reckoned with in this sport if he continues to stay active and improve. He fought just three weeks ago, so he should enter this bout in incredible shape to fight again.
LoCigno is 31 and reps Sityodtong Boston. LoCigno has fought three times as a pro, with all his fights taking place in Cage Titans. He's stopped every opponent he's faced, including in a win back in March. He is a high-level prospect in his own right but is taking a significant step up in competition as he takes on Eldridge.
I've liked LoCigno for a while now and have picked him to win all of his Cage Titans fights to date, but this will prove to be a tough fight for him, as I see Eldridge taking him to the mat and winning by submission.
Pick: Nick Eldridge -220, Under 1.5 Rounds -300
Bantamweight Bout (135 lbs): Cole Cameron (2-4) vs. Jacobo Apito (3-2)
Jacobo Apito -180
Cole Cameron +135
In a bantamweight contest, Jacobo Apito fights Cole Cameron.
Apito is 30 and fights out of Back 2 Basics in Cambridge, Massachusetts. He turned pro in 2019, and all his fights have been with Cage Titans. He scored a rarely-seen submission win via Tarikoplata at Cage Titans 68, showing off his dangerous ground game, and he will look to do the same thing here against Cameron.
Cameron is 31 and trains at Nick Catone MMA & Fitness in Brick Township, New Jersey. He went pro in 2024 and has been keeping busy, as this is his seventh fight in just over one year, including his third fight in 2025. Most of his fights have also ended inside the distance, although it is worth noting that he is coming off a submission loss in his last outing in April.
I expect this fight to end quickly, so I like the under 1.5 rounds at -300. As for a pick, I am going with Apito at -180, as I like his experience in Cage Titans, and he can win this fight by submission.
Pick: Jacobo Apito -180, Under 1.5 Rounds -300




